[Flash 9 is required to listen to audio.]
The Fiery Furnaces, “Cut the Cake”
Being a Fiery Furnaces fan is like being religious, because either one causes people to think you’re crazy and annoying. They are wary of you. Sometimes they squint their eyes when you tell them, as if you might be making up this ridiculous lie about yourself to seem funny.
Last week I saw the FF play in Northampton, MA. The Northampton crowd was small but one of the hipshakingest I have ever seen. (When Jonathan Edwards lived in Northampton, he was greatly disturbed by the youths’ habit of “night walking.” To my knowledge it was not a euphemism.) The band played like a huge machine, a steamroller, and “Single Again” rumbled so loud that I thought the floor would give out. Matthew Friedberger even seemed to be enjoying himself, which is hard to gauge since he keeps his cards close to the vest.
Eleanor’s phrasing is both stranger and more natural on the new album—you don’t notice how fucking weird it is until you sort out the words. In this song she writes to a newspaper editor to supply “all the answers they didn’t question”; the album is packed with wordplay like that that feels pleasing. It scratches a little itch but is never so clever that it becomes obnoxious. The strangeness gives the music a tension.
You know how there are two senses of ‘nostalgia’? There is yearning to return home, and there is yearning to return to the feeling of when you yearned to return home. I heard someone compare the first type to The Odyssey and the second to “Prufrock.”
The best Fiery Furnaces music, including much of their new album I’m Going Away, is suffused with that second type of nostalgia: wishing to return back to something, anxious, sad but conflicted about your sadness—conflicted enough that you start to wonder if you are actually sad after all. Like at the end of this song:
Who cut the cake?
Without any warning
Who cut the cake?
With my special knife
Into tiny little pieces for every fella’s wife
Is that sad? Is that regretful? Does she want to go back to before the cake got cut? I can’t explain what the lyrics mean, but I feel what the song’s about. Not to put too fine a point on the initial religious faith metaphor.